Why Kalen DeBoer argues that Alabama football “already feels” different in 2025

Certainly! Here’s an extended exploration of Kalen DeBoer’s argument that Alabama football “already feels” different in 2025, diving into the reasoning and nuances of how the program may be evolving.

Introduction

When Kalen DeBoer, the head coach of the Washington Huskies, made his statement that Alabama football “already feels” different in 2025, it raised eyebrows in the world of college football. Alabama, traditionally a powerhouse under Nick Saban’s guidance, has long been synonymous with dominance in the college football landscape. However, in recent years, some signs have pointed to subtle shifts within the program that may indicate a transition or evolution in the way the team operates, recruits, and competes. These changes have made it possible to view Alabama’s football culture from a different lens, one that perhaps marks a departure from the standard set over the last decade.

DeBoer’s statement is not necessarily an attack on Alabama’s program but rather an observation that the balance of power within college football, especially in the SEC, may be beginning to tilt. While Alabama still boasts immense talent and a rich history, some indicators suggest that the once-undeniable grip on dominance might be loosening. This article explores the different facets that contribute to this evolving dynamic within Alabama football and how Kalen DeBoer’s comment speaks to the larger shifting tides in college football in 2025.

1. The Changing Landscape of College Football

One of the first factors contributing to the perception that Alabama football feels different in 2025 is the evolving landscape of college football itself. The sport has undergone significant changes in recent years, including the introduction of the College Football Playoff (CFP), the NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) era, and realignment in conference structures.

The College Football Playoff (CFP) Era: The CFP has undoubtedly increased the level of competition for teams like Alabama, which had previously relied on the BCS system. The expanded playoff in 2024, with its larger bracket, means that more teams have a legitimate shot at the national title, making it harder for any single program to dominate the way Alabama did in the past. Historically, the Crimson Tide would often coast into the playoff, but with new faces rising, such as Georgia, Ohio State, Michigan, and even emerging programs, their status as the program to beat has been challenged.

The NIL Era: The introduction of NIL deals has been another transformative factor in college football. While Alabama remains one of the richest programs in terms of resources and recruiting power, the NIL landscape has introduced new challenges for every program, including the Crimson Tide. In the past, Alabama’s recruiting success was largely attributed to its ability to offer elite athletes the promise of championship contention, but NIL has added a new layer where players can make money while still choosing top programs. As a result, traditional powerhouses may not be able to rely solely on their past success to attract talent—other factors like NIL deals and social media influence are now at the forefront of recruitment, potentially shifting the balance of power.

Conference Realignment: The shifting dynamics of conference realignment have further complicated the landscape. Alabama has historically benefitted from the SEC’s status as the most competitive and prestigious conference, but realignment in 2025 is seeing new challengers emerge within the conference. The inclusion of Oklahoma and Texas, among others, makes the SEC even more competitive, and this added strength means that Alabama no longer walks through its schedule with the same level of certainty as before.

2. The Decline of Dominance Under Nick Saban

For over a decade, Nick Saban’s Alabama program defined college football. The team was a model of consistency, winning multiple national championships and regularly producing NFL talent. However, there have been signs in recent seasons that Saban’s grip on the sport may not be as strong as it once was.

The Shift in Recruiting: Historically, Saban’s recruiting success was unrivaled. Alabama consistently landed the top-ranked recruiting class and secured blue-chip prospects across every position. However, in 2024, there was a noticeable change in Alabama’s recruiting rankings. Other programs, particularly Georgia and Ohio State, have begun to keep pace with Alabama in terms of securing elite talent. With new competition on the recruiting trail, Alabama has had to adjust to a more crowded landscape, making it harder for them to simply out-recruit everyone else.

Quarterback Play and Offensive Innovation: Alabama’s offensive scheme, under Saban, was once a paragon of balance, focusing on a powerful running game and strong defense. However, the modern college game has shifted toward high-powered offenses, and Saban’s ability to adapt has been questioned in recent years. The program has struggled to find consistent quarterback play, and while Bryce Young was a star, there hasn’t been a clear successor who could lead Alabama’s offense with the same level of dynamism. In comparison, programs like Ohio State, USC, and even Washington have embraced a more pass-heavy attack with high-flying quarterbacks. Alabama’s slow adjustment to this trend has made it harder for them to keep up with the fast-paced, explosive offenses that dominate college football.

The Coaching Staff and Program Evolution: Another indication that Alabama is “feeling different” in 2025 is the change in coaching staff. While Saban has remained in control, the coaching staff has seen a series of departures, with several assistants leaving for head coaching positions or other opportunities. Saban’s longevity and success were, in part, due to his ability to consistently reload with top-tier assistants who could bring fresh ideas and coaching methods. However, the departure of some key figures has left Alabama without the same level of continuity in terms of the program’s leadership. This could lead to a shift in the program’s identity over time.

3. The Rise of Other Programs and Competition

While Alabama remains a top-tier program, the rise of other teams in the college football world has put more pressure on them to maintain their position. Programs that were once seen as regional powers or underdogs have made significant strides in recent years.

Georgia’s Ascension: Under Kirby Smart, Georgia has emerged as the new king of college football. Smart has built a program that not only matches Alabama’s physicality but also exceeds it in terms of overall team depth. The Bulldogs have been able to recruit at an elite level, with a focus on defense and an offense that is capable of keeping pace with the best teams. Georgia’s back-to-back national championships have demonstrated that Alabama no longer holds an unquestioned throne in the SEC.

Ohio State’s Consistency: Ohio State, under Ryan Day, has continued to excel as one of the most consistent programs in the nation. While Ohio State has not yet captured a national championship under Day, their regular appearances in the CFP and dominance in the Big Ten have positioned them as one of Alabama’s main competitors for the top spot. The Buckeyes’ explosive offense and solid recruiting efforts have kept them at the forefront of college football, competing with Alabama for national titles.

The Emergence of Other SEC Programs: While Alabama has traditionally dominated the SEC, the rise of other programs in the conference, such as LSU, Auburn, and Tennessee, has added another layer of competition. LSU, under Brian Kelly, is showing signs of returning to national prominence, and Tennessee, with Josh Heupel’s high-flying offense, has made waves in the SEC East. With more teams in the SEC capable of competing at the highest level, Alabama’s road to the top is more difficult than it has been in the past.

4. The Culture Shift in College Football

The overall culture of college football in 2025 is markedly different from that of the early 2000s or even the 2010s. With the impact of NIL, social media, and changing player empowerment dynamics, the nature of the game has evolved. Players now have more influence over their careers and decisions, and that shift in autonomy has affected even the most powerful programs, including Alabama.

Player Empowerment: One of the biggest changes in college football is the empowerment of players, particularly through NIL deals and the transfer portal. Players are no longer as dependent on the team’s long-term stability and can more easily transfer schools if they aren’t getting the playing time or NIL opportunities they desire. This has caused even elite programs like Alabama to adjust their strategies in recruitment, retention, and team management.

Social Media and Branding: Social media has altered the way college football programs brand themselves. While Alabama has a long history and reputation for success, the modern generation of athletes is looking for programs that align with their personal brand and allow them to build a platform on and off the field. The Crimson Tide, while still attractive due to their legacy, must contend with other programs that are more agile in utilizing social media and creating a more engaging and inclusive culture for players.