Ohio State and Notre Dame, two dominant collegiate football programs, have changed
Ohio State and Notre Dame are two of the most storied programs in college football history. With decades of success, Heisman winners, and a culture of excellence, both schools represent the pinnacle of the sport. However, the 21st century has brought changes to the collegiate football landscape, and these programs have adapted in ways that reflect both the challenges and opportunities of modern-day college football. From coaching transitions to roster management and the shifting power dynamics in conferences, Ohio State and Notre Dame have demonstrated their resilience and willingness to evolve.
Ohio State’s Transformation
Coaching Continuity and Innovation
Ohio State has experienced a relatively smooth transition between head coaches, ensuring continuity in its football philosophy while adapting to new challenges. The transition from Urban Meyer to Ryan Day in 2019 exemplifies this. Under Day, the Buckeyes maintained their offensive prowess while emphasizing quarterback development, a hallmark that has kept them competitive nationally.
The Buckeyes have also embraced innovation, particularly on the offensive side of the ball. Ryan Day’s schemes have integrated modern spread concepts with traditional power running, making Ohio State one of the most dynamic offenses in the country. This adaptability has been critical in their ability to compete with SEC powerhouses.
Recruiting in the NIL Era
Recruiting remains the lifeblood of Ohio State’s program, and the advent of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals has significantly altered the recruiting landscape. Ohio State has been proactive in helping players navigate the NIL system, ensuring they remain an attractive destination for top recruits. The Buckeyes’ ability to secure five-star talents like C.J. Stroud, Marvin Harrison Jr., and TreVeyon Henderson reflects their continued dominance on the recruiting trail.
Big Ten Expansion and the CFP
Ohio State has also benefited from the expansion of the Big Ten, with new additions like USC and UCLA elevating the conference’s national profile. The Buckeyes now face a more competitive regular-season schedule, preparing them for the rigor of the College Football Playoff (CFP). With the CFP expanding to 12 teams in 2024, Ohio State is well-positioned to make regular appearances in the postseason.
Notre Dame’s Evolution
A New Era of Coaching
Notre Dame underwent a significant change with the departure of Brian Kelly to LSU in 2021, marking the end of an era. Marcus Freeman, the former defensive coordinator, took the reins as head coach. Freeman brought a fresh energy to the program, emphasizing player development and a renewed focus on defensive excellence.
Under Freeman, Notre Dame has worked to modernize its approach while staying true to its identity. The team’s defense, long a strength, remains formidable, but the offense has seen a shift towards more dynamic playcalling and greater balance between the run and pass.
Embracing NIL and Academics
Notre Dame has historically placed a strong emphasis on academics, which can sometimes be a hurdle in recruiting compared to programs with fewer restrictions. However, the program has embraced the NIL era, creating opportunities for players to capitalize on their brand while maintaining the school’s high academic standards.
The Irish have also used their national brand to recruit players from across the country. Notre Dame’s ability to combine academic prestige with football excellence has allowed it to remain competitive in a rapidly changing landscape.
Independence and the Future
As one of the few remaining independent programs in college football, Notre Dame’s schedule remains unique. The Irish have managed to maintain a strong national schedule, facing teams from the ACC, Big Ten, and Pac-12. However, the question of whether Notre Dame will eventually join a conference remains a topic of debate, especially with the growing influence of conference realignment.
Notre Dame’s independence allows it to control its own destiny, but it also comes with challenges, particularly in the context of the expanded CFP. As more conferences grow stronger, the Irish may face increased pressure to align with a conference to ensure consistent playoff access.
Similarities Between the Two Programs
Shared Challenges
Both Ohio State and Notre Dame face challenges that come with being perennial contenders. Managing expectations, navigating the NIL landscape, and maintaining competitive rosters are constant concerns. Additionally, both programs must contend with the rising influence of conferences like the SEC and Big Ten, which continue to dominate the national narrative.
Commitment to Tradition
Despite these challenges, Ohio State and Notre Dame remain deeply committed to their traditions. From the iconic gold helmets of Notre Dame to Ohio State’s Script Ohio, both programs take pride in their history and fanbase. This commitment provides a sense of stability and identity as they navigate the modern era.
Recruiting Rivalries
The programs also frequently cross paths on the recruiting trail, vying for the same elite prospects. Their ability to attract top-tier talent while competing with other blueblood programs like Alabama, Georgia, and Clemson underscores their national appeal.
Differences in Strategy
Conference Affiliation
One of the most notable differences between the two programs is Ohio State’s affiliation with the Big Ten versus Notre Dame’s independent status. While Ohio State benefits from the resources and exposure provided by the Big Ten, Notre Dame’s independence allows for more flexibility in scheduling.
Offensive Philosophy
Ohio State has leaned heavily into a high-powered, quarterback-driven offense, while Notre Dame traditionally emphasizes a balanced attack with a strong running game. These philosophical differences reflect their respective approaches to competing on the national stage.
The Road Ahead
Ohio State’s Outlook
Ohio State’s future looks bright, with a roster loaded with talent and a coaching staff that continues to innovate. The addition of USC and UCLA to the Big Ten will create new challenges but also elevate the conference’s national profile. The Buckeyes are well-positioned to remain CFP contenders for years to come.
Notre Dame’s Path Forward
For Notre Dame, the focus will be on building consistency under Marcus Freeman and navigating the challenges of independence. The Irish must also find ways to maximize their recruiting efforts in the NIL era and continue scheduling marquee matchups to maintain their national relevance.
Ohio State and Notre Dame have undergone significant changes, adapting to the evolving landscape of college football while staying true to their rich traditions. Both programs face unique challenges and opportunities, but their commitment to excellence ensures they will remain central figures in the sport. As the game continues to evolve, Ohio State and Notre Dame will undoubtedly play pivotal roles in shaping the future of college football.
