“18-19 without a doubt,” “2024 not recency bias”: College basketball fans choose between Zion Williamson’s Duke teams and Cooper Flagg’s teams.

The debate among college basketball enthusiasts comparing the 2018-2019 Duke Blue Devils, led by Zion Williamson, to the 2024-2025 squad featuring Cooper Flagg, offers a compelling examination of talent, team dynamics, and performance.

2018-2019 Duke Blue Devils

The 2018-2019 team was renowned for its star-studded freshman class, including:

• Zion Williamson: Averaged 22.6 points and 8.9 rebounds per game.
  Sports Reference
• R.J. Barrett: Matched Williamson with 22.6 points per game and added 7.6 rebounds.
  Sports Reference
• Cam Reddish: Contributed 13.5 points per game.
  Sports Reference
• Tre Jones: Averaged 9.4 points and 5.3 assists per game.
  Sports Reference

This lineup propelled Duke to a 32-6 record, securing the ACC Championship and advancing to the Elite Eight in the NCAA Tournament.

2024-2025 Duke Blue Devils

The current roster is highlighted by:

• Cooper Flagg: A freshman guard/forward, recognized as a Preseason All-America First Team selection by the Associated Press.
  Duke University
• Tyrese Proctor: The sole returning starter, providing leadership and experience.
  WXII 12

While specific statistics for the 2024-2025 season are still unfolding, early performances, such as an 88-63 victory over Boston College where Flagg scored 28 points, indicate a promising trajectory.

Comparative Analysis

The 2018-2019 team was characterized by its explosive athleticism and offensive prowess, with Williamson and Barrett both earning AP All-America First Team honors.

Their chemistry and individual talents made them formidable opponents.

In contrast, the 2024-2025 team, though still early in the season, showcases a blend of youthful talent and seasoned leadership. Flagg’s immediate impact as a freshman and Proctor’s veteran presence suggest a balanced and dynamic team capable of adapting to various challenges.

While it’s premature to definitively compare the two teams’ legacies, the 2018-2019 squad set a high standard with their achievements. The 2024-2025 Blue Devils, under the guidance of Head Coach Jon Scheyer, have the potential to carve out their own distinguished place in Duke’s storied basketball history.